Democracy: dream/nightmare/illusion?

“If the president can start a conflict with an enemy as formidable as that on his own say-so, and the people’s representatives are so powerless to stop him that it doesn’t matter which party controls Congress, the age of America as a republic is truly over.”

… civically abhorrent yet morally just, ..

Nick Catoggio: Boiling Frogs 2 March 2026

I feel somewhat foolish. I forget that man has a powerful intellectual capacity …. which is subordinate to his emotions.

I think we all forget that quite often, when we think seriously.

This thought coalesced since the recent deaths of my brother and sister in law. Both in their 80’s and both long suffering from incapacitating and painful diseases. Death was a release for them, relief for loved ones – almost joy?

Why do we still have bouts of grief and almost guilt because of the relief?

It’s because our minds are not logical, objectively oriented or disciplined. We do not act upon our intellect but upon what emotions allow and sometimes compel us to.

We can behave and think and speak logically but that is a rigid controlled process which we do not maintain.

That is why democracy is a dream.

We know we should vote for the party that will serve us the best, says the right things and espouses our moral high ground. However sentiment and tradition drive our choices.

But wait, maybe Claude is the answer…!

Claude will allow us to build an avatar of ourselves.

My avatar, Mal II, will only think logically and consistently and cleverly. He/She/It will not be swayed by emotion, act on impulse, overreact or fail to act. Duty and mission will be observed continuously.

There won’t be mistakes …. will there…?

So we will vote for a candidate avatar, MP II, who will vote according to his/her/its promises and policies, with no knee jerk reaction to populist outcry, but rational. reasoned responses consistent with principles and policies.

Eventually everything will be as predicted and required, we will never make mistakes and tragedies will be coped with intellectually.

There will be no yin/yang, sturm und drang, joy and despair. Just straight roads, efficient systems, sufficient food, commonly accepted muzak and bland literature.

Brandolini’s Law: “The amount of energy needed to refute bulls—t is an order of magnitude bigger than that needed to produce it.” 

Kevin Williamson The Dispatch

Ja nee

Lulu got swooped by a butcher bird the other day; it clipped her bum and she leapt away. Quite funny, until it had a go at me..!

Magpies and kiewiets/plovers also get huffy. Being strafed while cycling is not amusing.

My Auntie Bunty said it was very frightening when it was a German bomber doing the strafing, which happened to her in WW2. Obviously they missed, as she told us the story.

It’s going to be one of those days with bits and pieces.

Such a moment in time, when the world makes kiss kiss to that awful orange man. Peace in Gaza was inevitable, there was nothing left. The Donald’s timing enabled him to claim the glory, but he was really only the final straw.

Let him crack the hard nut of the Ukraine and I will echo his own nomination for the Nobel Peace prize

“Journalism largely consists in saying ‘Lord Jones is dead’ to people who never knew Lord Jones was alive.” –G.K. Chesterton

“There is in our future a TV or Internet populism, in which the emotional response of a selected group of citizens can be presented and accepted as the Voice of the People.”  Umberto Eco

All issues are political issues, and politics itself is a mass of lies, evasions, folly, hatred and schizophrenia. 

George Orwell 

“The trouble with socialism is that eventually you run out of other people’s money.” 

Margaret Thatcher

… the Internet will bring about Idiocracy

Trump ….”tribalist, kleptocratic, authoritarian cultural imperialist? “

”  He cares about getting rich, persecuting his enemies, and eliminating threats to his own power—just like his Middle Eastern counterparts do. “

Nick Catoggio

A hit dog will holler. 

“Anyone who calls us authoritarian is going to prison,” 

“If you can’t call fascists fascists, then the fascists have won.”

Democracy insists upon enfranchising the ignoramuses, who also get a vote on any number of other issues about which they know little or nothing. Two cheers for democracy and all that.

United States and China are firmly locked in a cold war struggle whose outcome will be the most important determinant of peace, prosperity, and quality of life in international politics over the next decade.

The second half of this decade is set to be a critical inflection point in this contest.

Stephen Weber, Cold War Statecraft for the 2020s

We would be better off if we did a little bit more work understanding what people actually think (and why) rather than inventing arguments that are designed to make us feel virtuous in comparison. 

Kevin D Williamson TMD 24 Oct ’25

He was talking up the Ideological Turing Test which he believes will help us all avoid unsubstantiated sentimental pronouncements about others’ arguments.